Moneydesks

🛡️ Put options: the right to sell, as a bet or as insurance

Open this guide in the app →

🎯 In 30 seconds: A put gives its buyer the right to sell 100 shares at the strike price until expiration. A put buyer profits at expiration if the stock ends below strike minus premium, and can lose at most the premium. Puts can be a bet on a fall or insurance on shares you own. A put seller collects the premium and must buy 100 shares at the strike if assigned, even if the stock has collapsed. That is a large, real risk.

What a put is, in one line

A put option is a contract that gives you the right, but not the obligation, to sell 100 shares of a stock at a fixed price (the strike) until a fixed date (the expiration). You pay a premium for that right.

A put gains value when the stock falls. If you have the right to sell at $48 and the stock is at $40, that right is worth $8 per share, because you could buy at $40 and sell at $48.

New to the vocabulary? Start with What an option is, then Call options. Puts are the mirror image of calls.

Our hypothetical setup for this chapter: Company X trades at $50. A $48 put expiring in about 60 days costs $1.40 per share, or $140 per contract.

Buying a put: the three numbers

Maximum loss = premium x 100$1.40 x 100 = $140
Breakeven = strike - premium$48 - $1.40 = $46.60
Maximum gain = (strike - premium) x 100$46.60 x 100 = $4,660, only if the stock goes to $0

The profit or loss at expiration for one long put is:

P/L = (max(strike - stock price, 0) - premium) x 100

Unlike a call, a put's gain has a ceiling, because a stock cannot fall below zero. It is still a large ceiling compared with what you paid.

-$500$0+$500+$1,000$36$40$44$48$52$56Company X price at expirationProfit or loss, one contractBreakeven $46.60 Strike $48Max loss: -$140 (the premium)At $0 the gain wouldreach +$4,660
Buying one $48 put for $1.40. Above $48 you lose the $140 premium. Below $46.60 you gain $100 for every $1 the stock falls, up to $4,660 if Company X goes to zero.

Worked example: one put at five prices

Hypothetical. You buy one Company X $48 put for $1.40 and hold it to expiration.

Stock at expirationPut value per shareValue of 1 contractProfit or lossReturn on $140
$55$0$0-$140-100%
$48$0$0-$140-100%
$47$1.00$100-$40-29%
$46.60$1.40$140$00%
$42$6.00$600+$460+329%

The stock fell from $50 to $47, a 6% drop, and the put buyer still lost money. A put on a $50 stock with a $48 strike needs the stock to fall more than 6.8% by expiration just to break even. Being right about the direction is not enough. You need the size and the timing too.

Selling the put before expiration

As with calls, most put buyers close the position by selling the put back rather than exercising it.

Hypothetical. Twenty days after you bought, Company X drops to $46. With 40 days left, a pricing model values the $48 put at about $2.89.

Sold: $2.89 x 100$289
Paid: $1.40 x 100-$140
Profit before fees+$149

Its value at expiration with the stock still at $46 would be $2.00. The extra $0.89 is time value, which the market pays for the chance the stock falls further before expiration. See What an option is worth.

A put compared with short selling

The other way to bet on a fall is short selling: borrowing shares, selling them and buying them back later. Compare the two for 100 shares of Company X at $50:

Short 100 shares at $50Buy one $48 put at $1.40
Money at riskno fixed limit, losses grow as the stock rises$140, fixed
Stock rises to $65-$1,500-$140
Stock ends at $50$0, minus borrow fees-$140
Stock falls to $42+$800+$460
Time limitnone, but borrow can be recalledexpires in 60 days
Account neededmargin accountoptions approval

The put limits the loss and caps the cost of being wrong. You pay for that with the premium and the deadline.

Puts as insurance: the protective put

This is the oldest and most practical use of puts. You own 100 shares of Company X, bought at $50. You are worried about a drop over the next two months but do not want to sell. You buy one $48 put for $1.40.

Now, whatever happens, you can sell your shares for $48 until expiration. Your worst case is locked in:

Stock loss down to the strike: ($50 - $48) x 100-$200
Cost of the put-$140
Worst case, however far the stock falls-$340
New breakeven: $50 + $1.40$51.40
-$1,500-$1,000-$500$0+$500+$1,000$36$40$44$48$52$56$60Company X price at expirationProfit or loss on 100 shares bought at $50Put strike $48 Breakeven $51.40Floor: -$340Dashed: shares aloneSolid: shares + $48 put
Owning 100 shares at $50 with a $48 put. Below $48 the loss is frozen at $340: $200 of stock decline plus the $140 premium. The cost is that you need $51.40, not $50, to break even.

Without the put, a fall to $35 would cost $1,500. With it, the loss is $340. If the stock rises to $60 instead, you make $1,000 on the shares minus $140 for the put, so $860. You gave up $140 of upside to buy a floor.

The car insurance comparison fits. The strike works like the deductible: a $48 strike means you absorb the first $2 of the fall yourself. A higher strike gives better protection and costs more. A lower strike is cheaper and protects only against a bigger fall.

The trap: insurance you renew forever
Protection is not free, and it repeats. At these hypothetical prices, buying a fresh 60-day $48 put six times a year would cost about 6 x $140 = $840 a year on a $5,000 position, roughly 17%. That cost can eat most of a stock's long-run return. Many investors use puts for specific risky periods, or hedge with a cheaper structure such as a collar, instead of insuring all the time.

Selling (writing) a put

When you sell a put, you collect the premium and accept an obligation: if assigned, you must buy 100 shares at the strike. Your numbers are the put buyer's numbers flipped.

Maximum gain = premium x 100$140
Breakeven = strike - premium$46.60
Maximum loss = (strike - premium) x 100$4,660, if the stock goes to $0
-$1,000-$500$0+$500$36$40$44$48$52$56Company X price at expirationProfit or loss, one contractBreakeven $46.60 Strike $48Max gain: +$140 (the premium)At $0 the losswould be -$4,660
Selling one $48 put for $1.40. Above $48 you keep $140. Below $46.60 you lose $100 per $1, and if Company X went to zero you would lose $4,660.

Why would anyone take that trade? Some people want to own Company X anyway and would be happy to buy at $48. Selling the put pays them $140 while they wait. If assigned, their effective purchase price is $46.60, lower than the $50 the stock costs today.

The catch is what happens on bad news. Suppose Company X reports a disaster and falls to $30 before expiration. You must still buy 100 shares at $48:

Pay the strike: 100 x $48-$4,800
Shares are now worth 100 x $30$3,000
Premium you kept+$140
Loss-$1,660

A cash-secured put means you keep the full $4,800 in your account so you can always pay for the shares. A naked put means you sell it on margin without the cash set aside. That can force you to sell other holdings, or face a margin call, at the worst moment. Cash-secured puts and the wheel covers the strategy in detail.

One rule for put sellers
Only sell a put on a stock you would be content to own at the strike, in a quantity you could pay for in full. Before you sell, write the dollar loss if the stock fell 40% from today's price. For one $48 put on a $50 stock, that is 100 x ($48 - $30) - $140 = $1,660. If that number would hurt, the position is too big.

Early assignment on puts

Most US stock options are American style, so a put buyer can exercise any business day. A put that is deep in the money, with little time value left, is the kind most likely to be exercised early. If you sold it, you could be handed 100 shares before expiration without warning. See Exercise, assignment and expiration.

Try it

Pick a stock or broad index ETF you might hold for years and add it to your Watchlist. Look up a put about 5% below today's price, expiring in about two months. On paper, compute: the cost per contract, the worst-case loss on 100 shares with the put, the new breakeven, and the yearly cost if you renewed it six times. Then compute what a put seller at that strike would lose if the stock fell 30%. Write both answers in your trading journal.

Check yourself
  1. You buy one $48 put for $1.40. What are the maximum loss and the breakeven at expiration? Answer: Maximum loss is $140. Breakeven is $46.60 ($48 - $1.40).
  2. The stock falls from $50 to $47 by expiration. What happens to that $48 put? Answer: It is worth $1.00 ($100), so you lose $40. Being right about direction is not enough: you need the size and the timing too.
  3. You own 100 shares bought at $50 and buy a $48 put for $1.40. What is your worst case, and your new breakeven? Answer: The worst case is a $340 loss ($200 of stock decline plus the $140 premium), however far the stock falls. The new breakeven is $51.40.
  4. You sold a $48 put for $1.40 and the stock falls to $30. What is your loss? Answer: $1,660: you pay $4,800 for shares worth $3,000 and keep the $140 premium.

Sources